You’ve read about what a broomstick putter is and why so many golfers—amateur and professional alike—are giving it a try. But is a broomstick putter the right choice for you? In this post, we’ll walk you through the key signs and physical considerations that help determine whether switching to a broomstick putter is a smart move.
Why This Matters
Switching to a broomstick putter can radically change how you putt—for better or worse. Before you make the leap, it’s important to assess your current stroke style, physical needs, and putting performance. Not every golfer will benefit from a broomstick putter, but if you check a few boxes, it might be the missing link in your short game.
Signs You Might Benefit from a Broomstick Putter
1. You Struggle With the Yips
If you find your hands twitching or your wrists breaking down during the stroke, you’re likely dealing with the yips. Broomstick putters help by encouraging a wrist-free, shoulder-driven motion, reducing involuntary movements and building confidence.
2. Your Stroke Lacks Consistency
Inconsistent face angles and poor tempo are common culprits in missed putts. The length and split grip of a broomstick putter promote a pendulum-like stroke, often leading to more consistent contact and distance control.
3. You Fight Left/Right Misses (Pushes and Pulls)
Golfers who struggle to square the face at impact may benefit from the greater face stability that long putters provide. The split grip and extra stability help keep the face on line throughout the stroke.
4. You Get Nervous Over Short Putts
When the pressure’s on, shaky hands can ruin an otherwise good round. Broomstick putters reduce hand involvement and force you to rely more on larger muscle groups (shoulders and back), which are less susceptible to nerves.
Physical Considerations
Height and Arm Length
Taller golfers may find broomstick putters more comfortable because they promote an upright posture. That said, shorter players can still use them effectively with proper length fitting and grip adjustment.
Back and Neck Issues
Do you hunch over your putts? Broomstick putters allow you to stand taller, reducing strain on the lower back and neck—great for older golfers or anyone managing chronic pain.
Grip Comfort
The split grip used in broomstick putting may feel awkward at first. However, it often proves more ergonomic and can actually reduce hand and wrist fatigue over time.
Psychological Factors: Confidence Matters
Sometimes the biggest challenge in putting is mental. Broomstick putters:
-
Provide a new visual at address
-
Reinforce a sense of control
-
Help players commit to each stroke
Even if the mechanical changes are subtle, the confidence boost alone can make a measurable difference in performance.
When a Broomstick Might Not Be a Good Fit
-
You prefer a heavily arcing stroke
-
You rely on touchy, feel-based putting with lots of hand action
-
You dislike upright posture or standing close to the ball
-
You’re not open to a significant adjustment period
If you’re excelling with your current putter, a broomstick may be a solution looking for a problem.
A Quick Quiz: Should You Try a Broomstick Putter?
Answer “yes” to 3 or more of the questions below, and it’s probably worth a demo:
-
Do you miss short putts under pressure?
-
Have you struggled with the yips or hand tension?
-
Is your current stroke inconsistent in tempo or face angle?
-
Do you have physical discomfort when putting?
-
Do you want to simplify your putting stroke?
Final Thoughts
A broomstick putter isn’t just for golfers in crisis mode—it’s for any player looking for a more repeatable, stable stroke with less reliance on hand feel. If your putting is holding you back and you match the traits above, the broomstick could be a game-changing switch.
In the next post, we’ll explore how to choose the best broomstick putter for your game, including how to get the right fit, what features matter most, and which head shapes and grips to consider.
Discover more from Ten to Scratch
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.